University of Houston Cullen College of Engineering


UH Professor Discovers Issue at the Root of Seven-Year Water Dispute


Rashda Khan
Jeremy Palmer, assistant professor of chemical and biomolecular engineering at the UH Cullen College of Engineering, resolves water dispute.
Jeremy Palmer, assistant professor of chemical and biomolecular engineering at the UH Cullen College of Engineering, resolves water dispute.

Palmer uses programming experience to crack scientific stalemate

A scientific quest, started with genuine curiosity and a passion for research, turned into a Hatfield-McCoy style feud that lasted seven years. 

This legendary dispute and the man who finally resolved it – Jeremy Palmer, assistant professor of chemical and biomolecular engineering at the UH Cullen College of Engineering – are featured in an article titled “The war over supercooled water” published in Physics Today.

The beginning

Two teams of researchers – one at Princeton University and the other at the University of California, Berkley – worked to answer the same fundamental question: What happens when liquid water is cooled far below its freezing point?

Water that’s free of dust and other impurities on which ice crystals can form can be supercooled tens of degrees below 0 degrees Celsius. But all water in liquid form, no matter how clean, crystallizes at about -40 degrees Celsius in experiment.

Both teams wanted to know what theoretical models predict water might look like at even colder conditions. Each came up with a different answer.

Initially, the two teams started to work together to resolve the issue. But after a year, no consensus had been reached and the relationship had soured – each side convinced its answer and methods were correct. So started a scientific dispute conducted mostly via journal publications and conference presentations.

The stalemate continued until Palmer, then assistant professor at UH, dove deep into the Berkeley team’s computer code and discovered the error in their calculations.

Palmer, who earlier this year won a National Science Foundation CAREER Award, said reproducibility is a key part of the research process. He is creating a short course for graduate and undergraduate researchers at the Cullen College focused on whether findings by one research group can be reproduced by another.

“It’s a huge issue,” Palmer said. “Eighty percent of the work out there is not reproducible to the extent it should be.”

“If it can’t be reproduced, it’s not science,” he said.

To read the entire saga, visit Physics Today at:




Related News Stories

Distinguished Alumnus, Bilfinger Executive to be UH Cullen College Fall 2018 Commencement Speaker

Terrance “Terri” Ivers, P.E. (BSME ’80) is the fall 2018 UH Cullen College of Engineering commencement speaker.

Terrance “Terri” Ivers, P.E. (BSME ’80), is coming home to the UH Cullen College of Engineering as the featured speaker at its commencement on Dec. 13 at the NRG Arena. He received his Bachelor of Science degree in mechanical engineering from UH in 1980 and has remained involved in the Cullen College community throughout the course of his 37 year-long career.

Establishing Immunotherapy For Pediatric Liver Cancer

One of the most common forms of liver cancer in adolescents is hepatocellular carcinoma in which patient survival rates are under 30 percent. Photo courtesy: GettyImages

T-Cell Editor Creating Powerful Immunotherapy Weapon


As part of a $6 million effort to establish new therapies for high-risk pediatric liver cancer, Navin Varadarajan, associate professor of chemical and biomolecular engineering at the Cullen College of Engineering, will modify T cells to recognize and kill glypican-3, a molecule found in liver cancer cells.

Chemical Engineering Ph.D. Student Wins First Place at Society of Rheology Annual Meeting

Ali Slim, a UH doctoral student, wins Best Poster Award at the Society of Rheology meeting.

A multitude of everyday products – ranging from cosmetics and shampoo to computers and furniture – are made of composite materials. Composites are made by combining two or more natural or artificial elements, with the result being significantly different and often stronger than the original materials. Intrigued by the potential and properties of composites, Ali Slim chose to pursue a Ph.D.